Interesting take on Steve McNair's recent tragic death and the resulting media coverage from Rev. Joe Thacker over at The Winged Lion.
In particular, Rev. Thacker notes the exhortation of made by Bishop Joseph W. Walker III at McNair's memorial service:
Drop your stone the next time you write about Steve McNair. Drop your stone the next time you text somebody. Drop your stone the next time you twitter. Drop your stone, those of you in the barbershops, the beauty shops. Those of you walking the streets on the corner, drop your stone.
Thacker responds:
I assume the bishop’s comments stem from Jesus’ instruction in John 8:7: Let him who is without sin among you be the first to throw a stone…. If this assumption is correct, then I understand the bishop to be instructing his hearers that no one should judge Steve McNair in a negative light because all of us are sinners.
Well, there’s a modicum of truth in that, even as a sinner writes this post. However, does the fact that we are all sinners therefore mean that we are not to call sin “sin”? No, not at all, and Jesus wouldn’t have us to be so undiscerning. We are called to judge, but not to be hypocritical judges, keeping a healthy perspective on our own sin (see Matthew 7:1-5). We are to rightly view the sins of others, and be duly warned as a result (1 Corinthians 10:6-13).
...I can’t help but wonder that Bishop Walker would have been better served to instruct his listeners to learn from McNair’s folly. This isn’t to say that Steve McNair didn’t have many other fine qualities or that he didn’t significantly contribute to his community, for clearly he did. However, neither does this mean that we should pretend that his adultery was insignificant. It was significant, and it is significant to McNair.
One could argue that McNair actually took advantage of a troubled young woman and paid the ultimate price for his choice. As one sports pundit succinctly put it: "To many of his peers, it wasn't that he was fooling around with another woman, just the wrong woman."
As someone who once walked in McNair's shoes I'll now drop my stones, but Rev. Thacker provides some proverbial food for thought.
"They are what they do." -- Sportswriter Roger Angell, referring to professional athletes
Recent Comments